William Kovarik
Radford University
and
Matthew E. Hermes
Kennesaw State University

 

Fuels and Society C: 5. Impact on Fuels

6. Fuel Refinery Chemistry

Back to: Start


Dr. John Sinfelt, Inventor

Through a lifetime of study of small clusters of metal atoms - metallic clusters, Dr. John Sinfelt paved the way for efficient conversion of petroleum into useful fuels. Consider the before and after situation regarding TEL. Before its removal, oil companies wanted to have high quality fuels that contained BTX components, but they could make up deficiencies in fuel performance by the addition of TEL.

But after TEL was no longer allowed, fuels HAD to be better. And the amount of BTX components that would be necessary for the maintenance of fuel quality would be much larger than before the elimination of TEL.

That would require the costly construction of many new refinery operations to "reform" the fuel to high BTX levels.

But there is where Dr. Sinfelt's basic research paid off. He learned that selected metallic clusters catalyzed breaking of C-C and C-H bonds and dramatically increased the rate of chemical reactions that formed the BTX components. Dr. Sinfelt's timely inventions allowed much greater capacity amounts of reformulated fuel to be made in the same facility.

Dr. Sinfelt, a 1954 graduate of the University of Illinois in Physical Chemistry, based his success in the mathematical representation of the processes he studied. He could observe the results of an experiment conducted under specific experimental conditions in a specially designed reactor that mimiced, on a small scale, the refinery itself. But his greatest understanding came when he used the equations and symbols of mathematics to relate his observations to the known laws of kinetics and thermodynamics. If we read Dr. Sinfelts' published works, we are reading a mathematical interpretation and the successful predictions that emanated from this symbolic understanding.

  The TEL phase out meant that other ways would have to be found to boost octane levels. Ironically, most of the choices are the same as those Charles Kettering and the GM research team considered in the 1920s.
Petroleum Modifications: The first and most obvious way to make up the octane deficiency after a lead phase out was to further change refinery operations and increase the amount of aromatic constituents in the gasoline. BTX compounds (benzene, toluene and xylene) increased to more than 20% in the gasoline in the 1970's.

Domestic oil companies have had a century-long history of research to control the product that comes from refining of crude oil. Processes such as "Platforming", Powerforming" and "Ultraforming" were introduced long before the lead phase-out in order to improve the quality of the fuels by introducing branched chain and BTX compounds.6 – 1990 period. 


This is very much akin to simply adding benzene, as T.A. Boyd recommended in 1922. Its health effects are not as severe as lead, but they are significant, according to a World Bank study. While 5,000 Americans died every year as a result of heart disease from lead, some 47 people developed cancer from the use of benzene as a lead replacement.  “The health impacts of aromatics are several orders of magnitude less than that of lead,” the World Bank told a Nation magazine reporter.

Today's hydrocarbon fuel composition depends to a great extent on the catalytic processes invented by Dr. John Sinfelt at Esso Research in the 1960's.

Additives: Tertiary Butyl Alcohol, TBA( 2-Methyl-2-Propanol), with an octane number of 108, is an old stand by in the Sunoco system, and its use was more widespread after 1976. However, TBA had supply problems that prevented its use in treating the total production of gasoline. 

One newer alternative is MTBE (Methyl Tertiary Butyl Ether, also known as 2-methoxy-2-methylpropane). However, MTBE caused serious problems in water supplies, as we will see in section 26.

Finally, the oldest alternative fuel, ethanol, is being produced from farm products in the U.S. at around one percent of the total gasoline supply, and is routinely blended at 10 percent ratios with gasoline. Most sales are in the Midwest and in cities where winter smog is improved by adding an oxygenated fuel.

In the last ten years, gasoline overall composition has been changed (from that of gasoline sold as recently as 1990) to 1) include oxygenates; 2) reduce the content of olefinsand aromatics and volatile components, and 3) reduce the content ofheavy hydrocarbons to meet performance specification ozone-forming tendency and for release of toxic substances into the air from both evaporation and tailpipe emissions.

Gasoline composition is regional and seasonal. Winter gasolines must have higher volatility than those used in the summer. State and local laws preclude or include certain compositions. You can find one summary of the complex gasoline compositions at http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/steo/pub/special/rfg4.html#Summary

You might go on to fuel refinery chemistry or the reformulation process.

As MEH drove up I-70 in Colorado, west of Denver a couple of years ago, his 1993 Infiniti suddenly stalled out. he was at the entrance to the Eisenhower Tunnel, at an elevation of nearly 11,000 feet.


Eisenhower Tunnel as You Watch

That day was a brilliant, warm spring day that had followed a cold spell. The Colorado State Patrolman who rescued MEH told him to sit a while. His car would start when it had cooled down. He had a vapor-lock. The fuel in his carburetor had completely vaporized because of the low pressure at that altitude AND because of the warm day AND because they were still selling low-boiling, winter-formulated, volatile fuel in Steamboat Springs, Colorado where MEH had last filled his tank.
College of Science and Mathematics
Kennesaw State University
1000 Chastain Rd.
Kennesaw, GA 30114
770-423-6160
 
t_logo.gif (12525 bytes) ChemCases.com is a National Science Foundation supported curriculum development project.