Refrigerants for the 21st Century
9. Proof of CFC Damage

SPECULATION ABOUT AND PROOF OF OZONE DAMAGE FROM CORE CONCEPTS OF KINETICS, EQUILIBRIUM AND ANALYTICAL MEASUREMENTS
Less than a year after Rowland and Molina's publication, chemists, physicists and atmospheric scientists came together to try to find out if the threat of CFC's to the stratospheric O3 layer is real. At the 169th National American Chemical Society (ACS) Meeting in Philadelphia, a vigorous panel discussion was held. At about the same time, the National Research Council (NRC) named a panel, chaired by Dr. H.S. Gutowsky, University of Illinois, to study the problem.

The problem, at first, was daunting since there was essentially no scientific evidence. In addition, not only chemistry, but meteorology and astronomy, had to be considered to approach an accurate understanding. Besides the reaction schemes proposed by Rowland and Molina, other chemical equilibria and kinetics involving different stratospheric species (nitrogen and sulfur compounds, particulates) probably contribute to the overall chemistry of O3. Winds, volcanic eruptions, sun spot activity - all affect what's going on up there. An idealized, global-encompassing picture of the stratospheric O3 layer is just not realistic.
NASA scientists have attempted a comprehensive electronic textbook of ozone atmospheric dynamics.  This extraordinary effort should be examined by any student who desires to go deeply into ozone study.

Because of the complexity of the atmosphere, scientists resorted to computer modeling to try to include as many variables as possible. Even so, the best that could be hoped for was a two dimensional model.

Initial attempts at stratospheric measurements of key chemical species were very crude. However, laboratory experiments about equilibria and kinetics showed which molecules and free radical species should be most important to O3 chemistry.

Watch the 1998 Ozone Hole Grow
ephole98.gif (905702 bytes)

This gif image will refresh for each day.  The Ozone Hole is considered to be below 220 Dobson Units on the color bar - violet-purple.The black circle is the southern hemisphere's night.  You may want to clear your cache to view this image.  See the Ozone Hole Page


While the scientists scurried to develop an understanding of the problem, politicians, civic leaders and manufacturers of CFC's had to take positions. There were calls for boycotts of CFC-containing products. Some companies voluntarily chose to eliminate CFC's from their products. A representative of Dupont, the world's largest producer of CFC's, at the the Philadelphia ACS meeting, stated that their production must cease IF the theory could be shown to be correct. In 1979 the U.S. government and those of some Scandanavian countries chose to ban the use of CFC's in aerosol products (except for a few critical medical applications, such as anti-asthma inhalers). At the time aerosols were the largest (28%) single use of CFC's.

With the U.S. government ban on CFC-using aerosol products, there was a temporary leveling off of in CFC's production. The ban would have had a more dramatic effect if most of the other nations of the world had followed suite. After all, the problem of atmospheric pollution is worldwide. By 1985, the CFC's production rate was again growing - at a 3%/year rate. Countries from around the world met for the first time, in Geneva, Switzerland in 1985, and signed a convention calling for negotiators to make plans for a worldwide course of action based on the latest scientific information. Not only CFC's but Br-containing halons as well were to be included in computer-generated models.

The first concrete evidence for stratospheric O3 damage came in 1985 when British scientists reported finding dramatic declines in the springtime O3 values above the Antarctic. The "hole" was first detected in the mid-1970's through analytical samples taken in the stratosphere using instruments attached to huge balloons.

You can see a profile of current ozone concentrations in the upper atmosphere as reported by NASA.


Concept Map for this ChemCase

Fluorocarbon Alternatives
Case Study: Ozone Layer Degradation

Or move on to

10. The Montreal protocol
11. Identifying Alternatives
Previous Section (8. CFCs and the Ozone Layer)
Refrigerants ChemCase home page
ChemCases.com home


Principal Investigator Laurence Peterson; Project Director Matthew Hermes;
Author of this module William Gumprecht.